Having used both of these, there really is not a clear winner in which software is. No, there is no technical support offered for the free version of edrawings for pro engineer. To publish edrawings you must have either pro engineer 2000i 2, pro engineer 2001, pro engineer wildfire or pro engineer wildfire 2. Top 10 reasons why more engineers are choosing pro. If you currently have an active perpetual license for pro e, you will not be forced into the subscription model and your existing contract will be honored. Modelling featuresin terms of features, pro e was built to do a lot and it certainly does this efficiently. I think solidworks interface is easier than proe and it is suitable only for medium scale industries where cost of software package and complexity is the main factor. These opinions are clearly shaped by the rivalry between creo, formerly pro engineer pro e and solidworks. Ptc creo, formerly known as pro engineer is a parametric, integrated 3d cadcamcae solution created by parametric technology corporation ptc. Im graduating college this spring, and when i do ill miss just about everything about this school. Sep 15, 2010 however, cam is a lousy excuse for using pro e because both inventor and solidworks can be coupled with excellent cam software like mastercam to give the same or better results. Feb 21, 2020 pro e wildfire creo parametric tutorials 3d parametric solid model drawing. Dec 30, 2017 pro engineer tutorial for beginner 1 pro e sketcher tutorial. Creo vs solidworks ability to tell the software to look at a new reference.
Proe is still around in some capacities but its mostly. Im just so used to ptc that i can do stuff with my eyes closed. Since then, solidworks has been increasing their abilities while pro engineer now creo chased their inferior tail. Proe and creo accept only ascii characters in their file names.
Our toolmaker can whip out a nice model and drawing fast. Oct 31, 20 only catia and pro e creo have the ability to make the more advanced models. For the first 10 years, ptc generally released 2 versions per year, with some exceptions. This is the first cad software that i learnt properly before discovering that it was the most difficult and obsolete. Pro engineer tutorial for beginner 1 pro e sketcher. Proengineer wildfire ptc windchill software vuforia chalk floefd for. Solidworks can build 3d curves using what it calls a 3dsketch. At the end of the day, those differences can make or break the success of. Serious comparison between solidworks and creo proe. Dec 11, 2018 the apps closest in competition include software such as catia, siemens nx and solidworks are creo elementspro and creo parametric. Find training, consulting, purchase or take a free demo. At a previous position we had proe, wildfire, inventor and solidworks. I hear solidworks is great but it does have some weaknesses compared to pro e. Utilizing a variety of handson lessons, this book introduces students to the basics of proengineer wildfire, one of the most widely used cadcam software programs in the world.
What is the difference between proe, solidworks, and. These opinions are clearly shaped by the rivalry between creo. Proengineer wildfire creo, windchill, and 3d printers. Proengineer is now creo proengineer is now ptc creo, but its not just a name change its so much more. Ive been using proe and creo for 17 years and ive just started learning solidworks recently. Since the last release of pro e, ptc has modified their licensing models to only offer subscription licenses. This free download is the standalone setup of pro engineer for windows 32bit and 64bit. Creo, like its proe predecessor, allows multiple sequential commands all in one shortcut.
Creo is a suite of solutions offering integrated 3d cadcamcae software. Something like 300k lines of code removed because it did nothing. Get a full creo vs solidworks comparison here at scan2cad. The focus of pro engineer at one time was to be the very best possible, but they got greedy and solidworks came along with a midrange approach and began eating the pro e lunch. Pro e is a 3d cad application developed by the parent company, ptc. But i have heard nothing but good things about solid works and ideas too. Every software having some ups and down but for me solidworks is the best software tool. Creo elementspro, or creo elementsdirect modeling, formerly known, together with creo parametric, as proengineer and wildfire, is a solid modeling or cad, cam, cae, and associative 3d modeling. Comparison between proengineer and solidworks youtube. Oct 28, 2003 solidworks cant assign tangency or c2 matching at curve endpoints. Ptc claimed that when they released wildfire 1, they had done an extensive search and removal project to get rid of unused subroutines. I used solidworks quite a lot, and pro e during one year and catia now. Oh, and if youre running wildfire and you open up a file that you created using pro e 2001, wildfire corrupts the file so that you cant open it in 2001 anymore.
This is from someone who has been around both systems for many years, and is. Proe wildfire enables designers to adjust curves with sliders and then assign tangency and c2 matching to existing model surfaces, solid faces and edges. Jan 21, 2017 pro engineer wildfire 5 is a powerful 3d modeling tool by ptc with all the necessary features and options. Many of these engineers have been involved in construction since the 2d era of the cad world and know 3d cad systems from the early days. Being a former pro e user 2001 i2 i am immediately drawn to pro e wildfire. That debate has raged for years, and here is some more fuel to the fire. I find solidworks a chore, but its much more to do.
It was the first to market with parametric, featurebased, associative solid modeling software. If you currently have an active perpetual license for proe, you will not be forced into the subscription model and your existing contract will be honored. Basically, if you dont do everything perfectly as youre supposed to. Proengineer wildfire is now ptc creo the software package that was previously sold as proengineer wildfire is now called ptc creo parametric, a full suite of 2d and 3d cad software. This is a basic beginner tutorial for pro engineer. They are much weaker when it comes to free form surfacing and engineering functions. Since the last release of proe, ptc has modified their licensing models to only offer subscription licenses. Jun 10, 2011 pro e vs solidworks vs catia both pro e or creo, catia and solidworks are the most powerful 3d modeling softwares in the world today. One plus with solid works it is a bit cheaper than pro e and it has a very basic fea package bundled in. Unsure as to why you should upgrade from proengineer wildfire proe to creo.
Table of file types and compatibility solidworks proe. Proe 1 point 5 years ago ill agree with on some of the downsides of creo, but some of the ones you mention are, i think, based on your higher familiarity with sw. The software comes equipped with the tools integrated into different suites for modelling. But this is all ancient history, how does solidworks compare to ptc creo today. The main difference between the software besides functionalities, such as surface modeling is at what kind of company or position they are used. Solidworks vs wildfire mouse clicks and travel ptc.
Both operators are experts at surfacing and product design professionals, and both work for the product design school called designengine education. Comments made about proewildfirecreo being more difficult to use are. I still contend that if i sat down with the last menu based version of proe 2000i or i2 i believe i could outperform an experienced user at a wildfire seat with respect to general modeling and assembly. Download proengineer wildfire 5 offline iso free all pc world. The fact is, there are a number of significant differences between mcad software systemsand the companies that make them. The main difference between the software besides functionalities, such as. The presenters are also keen to each others modeling techniques and work flow suspecting that they will show more.
Both operators are experts at surfacing and product design professionals, and both work for the product design school called. Design and engineering software packages overview design. I think solidworks interface is easier than pro e and it is suitable only for medium scale industries where cost of software package and complexity is the main factor. Whilst most other software at the time were primarily 2d, proengineer was based on solid.
If you follow the complete series of procedures, you will learn how pro engineer passes 3d design information to and from every design stage, from solid part creation, to part assembly, to the. Creo elementspro, or creo elementsdirect modeling, formerly known, together with creo parametric, as pro engineer and wildfire, is a solid modeling or cad, cam, cae, and associative 3d modeling application, running on microsoft windows it is the direct modeling application of a suite of 10 that provide collaborative solid modeling, assembly modeling, 2d orthographic views, finite element. Proe wildfire, solidworks 2004, or sdrc ideas cad software. Weve always believed that ptc creo is the best 3d cad program on the. Two of the most popular 3d modeling software applications that are used in the industry today are proe and solidworks. I dont know if they released an improved version of their ui, but it was really bad. At the time, proengineer did cost significantly more and it was. Mainly because a former coworker speaks strongly about it too. This software application was one of the pioneers in engineering design. Proe, proengineer, prohelp, prointralink, promechanica, protoolkit, product first, product development means business, product makes the company, ptc. What is the difference between proe, solidworks, and catia. About anycad and importing files from other cad systems. Our company is thinking about changing our cad software after years from using pro e wildfire to solidworks. Access free solid modeling using pro engineer wildfire book was created prior to solidworks and was pioneering in the range of tools it brought.
Most of us defaulted to solidworks when there wasnt a client requirement to use the other software. Having used both of these, there really is not a clear winner in which software is better. We could of saved a lot of money never getting pro e. Over time and in countless benchmarks proe, temporarily called wildfire, proved how good the function and the speed of the program is. The industry standard for product design and development software for parametric modeling, simulationanalysis, and product documentation for more than 30 years. The debate on creo vs solidworks has gone a long time, and its not over. Ptc creo, formerly known as proengineer is a parametric, integrated 3d cadcamcae solution created by parametric technology corporation ptc. The electronic data format of edrawings files is highly compressed to. Both have very similar tools and use the same tools in slightly different manors on how to create a 3d model. Table of file types and compatibility solidworks proe wildfire ansys 8. Creating a concentric hole on a cylinder video tutorial pro e wildfire 5. What is the best software to design 3d, other than solidworks. I think pro e is really more powerful, but its ergonomics and usability are crap.
Despite being overshadowed by more sophisticated solid modelers such as solidworks and creo or proe in the mechanical design and product development fields over the years it still tends to be a default. Jun 23, 2006 solidworks is generally easier to use and functions for many many design issues. Getting started with pro engineer wildfire is a tutorialbased introduction to creating parts, assemblies and drawings in pro engineer. If you look at my list, obviously i currently lean towards pro e.
Though there are lots of people who have used both that never want to go back to pro e. That being said i used sw for 6 months 6 years ago and have used proe consistently since then, so maybe i dont know how great sw is. It is funny to me that people always try to make the comparison from pro to sw. Download proengineer wildfire 5 offline iso free all pc. I think the only reason we have pro e is because our big aerospace customers have it.
Comparison between catia, soldiworks, creo, nx, etc. For solidworks, use solidedge or inventor for an apples to apples comparison. The presenters will both be using pro e wildfire 5. Pro e is better for assembly in mechanism is so nice to use, rounds, orientating sketches, and better for changing features, the interface for the rest of the company like the mold programs and such. With creo parametric, users can create and develop complex surface geometry using a range of featuresfrom sweeps to blends to offsetsand freestyle modeling capabilities. Ptc provides the leading cad application in the graphics designing industry for both educational and professional. I deal with swx and catia mostly, but i have some experience with proe wildfire, creo, and nx. Catia and solidworks are both developed by dassault systemes 3ds. Pro e allows you to apply endconditions to the cos curvature, etc to any type of planeedgesurface. Solidworks uses bezier and might be a bit harder to control, compared to the pro engineer cos curve on surface function, which is a nurbs curve in the interactive module in pro e called isdx. They both give an engineer the edge of making a design which he can rotate to view in 3d and assemble many of these 3d models to make an assembly of your actual design allowing you to make a much more detailed.
1237 259 1214 265 285 1450 78 55 1606 996 849 734 1605 838 1336 1374 1330 639 1080 1570 1563 1478 1144 1283 47 936 798 885 1254 166 922 1032 1373 1499 711 872 197 389